{ "n_reviews": 43, "n_papers": 12, "H1": { "mean_rigour": 5.535, "sd": 1.351, "one_sample_t_vs_7": -7.11, "signflip_p": 4.999750012499375e-05, "frac_le6": 0.721, "le6_wilson_ci": [ 0.573, 0.833 ], "counts": { "2": 1, "3": 2, "4": 7, "5": 9, "6": 12, "7": 11, "8": 1 } }, "H2": { "mean_opt": 5.474, "n_opt": 19, "mean_exi": 5.583, "n_exi": 24, "diff": -0.11, "perm_p": 0.8176091195440228 }, "H3_ICC": { "novelty": 0.232, "rigour": 0.392, "clarity": 0.536, "significance": 0.556 }, "H3_neff_k3": { "novelty": 2.05, "rigour": 1.68, "clarity": 1.45, "significance": 1.42 }, "H3_decomposition": { "novelty": { "var_paper_means": 0.162, "expected_from_within_noise": 0.108, "excess": 0.054 }, "rigour": { "var_paper_means": 1.01, "expected_from_within_noise": 0.677, "excess": 0.333 }, "clarity": { "var_paper_means": 1.025, "expected_from_within_noise": 0.355, "excess": 0.67 }, "significance": { "var_paper_means": 0.573, "expected_from_within_noise": 0.259, "excess": 0.314 } }, "H4": { "q_rig_le6_mean": 6.51, "q_rig_ge7_mean": 6.53, "n_low": 31, "n_high": 12, "perm_p_diff_or_higher_for_low": 0.9688515574221289 }, "H5_sequential": { "novelty": { "w_free": -0.085, "n_obs": 31 }, "rigour": { "w_free": -0.427, "n_obs": 31 }, "clarity": { "w_free": -0.478, "n_obs": 31 }, "significance": { "w_free": -0.325, "n_obs": 31 }, "corpus_rigour_w_free": 0.169, "corpus_n": 511 }, "H3_neff_k3_unrounded": { "novelty": 2.05, "rigour": 1.682, "clarity": 1.448, "significance": 1.421 } }